Hogfish Fillet Sandwich with Coconut Bread 

Jun 28, 2022All Recipes, Main Courses

It’s an outstanding combination of flavour and texture. Hog fish (a.k.a Hogsnapper) is a flaky 

white fish with sweet undertones and a flavour profile of scallops and lobster, paired with 

coconut bread is next level euphoria. 

Serves 4 


Canola or vegetable oil for frying 

2 lbs (1 kg) Hog snapper fillet, cut into 1-inch 

(2.5 cm) thick strips, or halved crosswise 

2 Tbsp (30 mL) recipe Bahama Fish Seasoning 

2 cups (500 mL) evaporated milk or buttermilk 

2 egg whites, lightly beaten 

1 ½ cups all-purpose flour 

1 ½ cups cornstarch 

1 Tbsp (15 mL) coarsely ground black pepper 

8 slices, coconut bread, lightly toasted, divided 

1 Recipe Sweet Peppery Tartar Sauce, divided 

4 green leaf or boston lettuce, divided 

8 slices ripe small tomatoes, divided 

1 cup (250 mL) store bought pickled red onions, divided 

½ cup (125 mL) Island Gurl Foods Pepper Sauce, divided 

Fresh dill for garnishing 

Lime wedges for garnishing 

1. Preheat a deep fryer with oil to 350˚F (180˚C). 

2. Pat fillets dry with paper towels, set aside on a plate, season both sides lightly with fish 


3. In a large bowl, whisk together the milk and eggs, set aside. Mix the flour, cornstarch, and 

ground pepper in a glass dish to set up a dredging station. 

4. Add fillets one at a time to the milk mixture to cover, transfer to flour mixture and coat on 

both sides of the fillets. 

5. Transfer to the preheated oil and fry until golden, about 5 minutes or until an instant-read 

thermometer inserted into the thickest part reaches and internal temperature of 145°F (62.8°C). 

Set aside on a cooling rack placed over a baking sheet lined with parchment and keep warm. 

Repeat with the other fillets. 

6. To assemble the sandwich, spread the tartar sauce over both slices of breads, add a slice of 

lettuce, fillet, 2 tomatoes, onions, drizzle tartar sauce, pepper sauce, serve open-faced garnished 

with dill and a lime wedge. Repeat with the other sandwiches, serve at once with plantain chips, 

side salad or fries. 

Bahama Fish Seasoning 

Here’s a recipe for the traditional method of seasoning fish in the 


Makes 3 Tbsp (45 mL) 


2 Tbsp (30 mL) sea salt 

1/2 Scotch bonnet or habanero pepper, finely diced (using food safety gloves) 

1. Place salt and pepper on a cutting board. Use the blade of a knife and mince together. 

2. Store in an airtight container for up to 1 month. 

Sweet Peppery Tartar Sauce 

This sauce is a perfect accompaniment to seafood. 

Makes 1 1/2 cups (375 mL) 


2 cups (500 mL) mayonnaise with olive oil 

2 tsp (10 mL) Dijon mustard 

2 Tbsp (30 mL) lemon juice 

½ cup (125 mL) dill pickles, diced 

1/4 piece roasted red bell pepper, puréed 

1/4 cup (60 mL) sweet relish 

1 Tbsp (15 mL) capers 

fine sea salt to taste 

1. Add mayonnaise to a small bowl, add mustard, lemon juice and whisk. 

2. Add pickles, puréed bell pepper, relish, capers, and mix. Taste and adjust 

with salt if necessary. 

3. Store in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 2 weeks. 

More Recipes from Island Gurl Foods

Jamaican Pepper Shrimp

These shell-on shrimp with a subtle spicy flavorful heat is the perfect appetizer or snack at the table. Serve over pasta for a scrumptious meal. MARINATING TIME: 30 MINUTES | COOKING TIME: 6 MINUTES | SERVINGS: 4 Ingredients 1 lb. large shell-on shrimp, preferably...

Smoky Mango Jerk Chicken

A wonderful balance of traditional Jamaican Jerk spices with a subtle hintof tropical mango to balance the flavourful heat. COOKING TIME: 20 MINUTES | SERVINGS: 4 Ingredients 4 chicken leg quarters (or 1 whole chicken,cut into quarter pieces)seasoned salt to taste...

Blackened Rainbow Trout with Strawberry Salsa

Get your pan sizzling hot for this sweet rainbow trout spicy makeover. Paired with a sweet, tart and crunchy Strawberry Salsa, for a go-to fast weekday meal. Leftover salsa would be delicious tossed with greens or spooned over...

Tropical Mango Cheesecake

Mango is hands-down my favourite fruit. With nuances of orange, peach and melon, it’s like no other fruit. Ripe Kent, Palmer or any other type of non-fibrous mangoes are preferred for this bright and citrusy cheesecake. Serves 8 INGREDIENTS Crust 4 cups (1 L) honey...


Mad Mac & CheeseBahamian mac and cheese (aka macaroni) is the most rich,luscious and cheesy baked dish. Every family takes pride in theirrecipe. However, my girlfriend, Maddie, makes the most illustriousmacaroni in the Bahamas. I’ve added a few ingredients to put...

Pigeon Peas & Dumpling Soup!!!

No better way to shake the winter blues than diving into a bowl of this luscious, protein rich soup filled with yummy dumplings! Follow me as I guide you step by step, and instruct you on how to make this wonderful recipe from my childhood. Watch my video...

Guava BBQ Beef Ribs

Tropical sweet guava BBQ enhances the flavor of smoky grilled meats. Serve these ribswith your favorite sides and make new memories with these next level BBQ ribs. COOKING TIME: 2 HOURS 30 MINUTES | SERVINGS: 4 Ingredients 2 racks Beef Grilling Back Ribs(about 7 ribs...

Spicy Maple BBQ Rainbow Trout

Real maple balances the heat of citrussy Habanero chilies a perfect glaze for tender, flaky Rainbow Trout. COOKING TIME: 8 MINUTES | SERVINGS: 4 Ingredients 4 Rainbow Trout Fillets (4 oz/125g each)fine sea salt to taste (optional)3 Tbsp (45 mL) vegetable or canola...

Bahama Steamed Chicken

A tasty dish with a zesty tomato-based sauce that complements all proteins and vegetables. It’s paradise in a bottle. COOKING TIME: 30 MINUTES | SERVINGS: 4 Ingredients 4 boneless skinless chicken breasts or thighs(4 oz/125g each)Salt and pepper to taste3 Tbsp...

Caribbean Three Milk Cake

Caribbean Three Milk Cake 1 ½ cups (375 mL) local Ontario Milk 1Tbsp (15 mL) Ontario Butter, softened 1 Tbsp (15 mL) All-purpose flour, for dusting 2 cups (500 mL) All Purpose flour ¼ tsp salt 2 tsp baking powder ½ cup (125...

Mexican Turkey Tortilla Soup

Turkey takes a Mexican twist here.  Use your leftover turkey to create this flavourful festive soup.  Preparation Time: 15 minutes Cooking Time: about 30 minutes Serves 6 2 tbsp (25 mL)        vegetable oil 2        ...

Carrot Cake Smoothie Bowl

All the flavours of carrot cake in a bowl for breakfast! Choose your favourite toppings or stick to the traditional walnuts, pumpkin seeds and finely chopped apples. Freeze Greek yogurt in an ice cube tray to make it cold and slushy.  Preparation Time: 5 minutes...

Bircher Muesli

Oats are soaked beforehand instead of cooked in the morning, making it an ideal healthy breakfast for time-starved cooks. While the recipe originates in Switzerland, it makes use of Ontario’s apples, honey or maple syrup and calcium-rich dairy. Preparation Time: 5...

Roasted Sweet Potato and Beet Sunflower Salad

This salad of sunny-coloured vegetables with Ontario sweet potatoes and beets, tossed with an enticing sunflower butter dressing, brightens up a winter day. Roast the vegetables and whisk up the dressing the night before and you’ve the makings of a lunch. Preparation...